Why no Trailseeker/R2 comparisons?

[mkg3]

As a last generation Outback owner, I find the new Outback a mistake. The sales have dropped and if I wanted a Subaru SUV, there already was the Forester (I know its bit smaller), or Ascent. What make Outback unique was the wagon aspect, just as Volvo V60 was and Audi A6 Alltrack (now coming back).

If I was looking for an EV from Subaru, it would not be one one the plastic cladded Toyota variant. If that's what I wanted, I would either just get a Toyota or Lexsus version.

Sponsored

 

[Yamazaki]

It really is. If they had released a viable Crosstrek or Forester equivalent, but as a quality EV, I would 100% already own one. The current crop of rebranded Toyota EVs isn't good enough for me to switch. I'm all in on Rivian now.

That's kind of where I am right now. I've been a Subaru fanboy for a long time now, but I really want to cross to the EV world and Subaru's offerings haven't been strong. The only things that are giving me pause on the R2 are little quality-of-life things that my 4'10" wife has come across.

1) She has to jump to hit the close button on the rear hatch for the R2 since the height can't be programmed, but the Trailseeker has a foot-triggered sensor underneath and probably can program the height (will test that tomorrow).

2) Even with the seat all the way forward and up, her feet barely touch the pedals in the R2. If we get one, I will have to modify it so that she can sit securely in the seat. I don't expect the Trailseeker to have that issue since none of our current or previous Subarus have ever had that problem.

3) We don't have CarPlay, but she uses her phone for everything - navigation, audio, etc and I listen to FM radio exclusively. There are already threads on this and the Trailseeker doesn't have this problem.

4) She doesn't like that there are no grab handles in the R2. When we go off-road, she gets tossed around a lot and holds onto the grab handles for dear life. She's not sure what will happen in the R2.

5) Reliability. I expect the R2 to be better than what I've read about the R1, but I'm doubting the R2 will get to 280,000 miles like my '04 Forester. If the work is mechanical, I'm able to do a limited amount, but we'll see how easy a car that puts the battery under the seat is to work on...

 

[KBabione]

That's a gripe I have about buying a car in the US - Dealerships. I hate that sales model. They are not incentivized to sell EVs, so they don't even try. When I took my Forester in for a recall service earlier this year, I asked for a Solterra as a loaner car. They said "sure, but why would you want that?" It's true it wasn't super amazing, but why would you talk crap about your own car?

I too hate the dealership model. Your quote made me laugh - When our Outback was in for a major service and it would be all day I asked if they had a Solterra loaner. They did, but it took them 20 minutes to find the key because it's just been sitting there for weeks! This was about two years ago and I was hoping to talk the family into getting one as a bridge until we got the R2. They thought it was cheap looking - both inside and out so I was vetoed. It was a nice way to get a test drive without a sales person following up though.

 

[CharonPDX]

"similar ground clearance"??? Look at the chin spoiler of the Subby, now compare that to the R2, not even close.

Far closer to R2 than any other similar-market EV.

8.3 inches clearance.

No, it's no R2, and definitely no R1S, but it's way more of an offroad vehicle than pretty much any other non-Rivian EV wagon/SUV. (Barring the absolutely ridiculously priced things like the Mercedes G-wagen.) Which makes it a fair comparison. It's the most offroady R2 competitor.

 

[jrmbadger]

The 2026 Subaru/Toyota EVs are markedly better than the previous year. They used to be trash, now they're entirely adequate.

I stand by my earlier criticisms of Toyota. Just watched this Trailseeker Review and while they seem to be moving in the right direction at 8:18 he mentions that there is NO route planner on the navigation to plan charging stops. Yikes.

 

[DuoRivian]

I stand by my earlier criticisms of Toyota. Just watched this Trailseeker Review and while they seem to be moving in the right direction at 8:18 he mentions that there is NO route planner on the navigation to plan charging stops. Yikes.

Yes the software has gaps (the route planned will be there by year end for the Highlander) and there are some other issues but fundamentally a good driving car that is efficient (3.7+ miles/kWh), well priced, light (4500lb) and spacious.

 

[LevelHeaded]

Calling any Subaru an off-roader is laughable

as has been established, the R2 is approximately equivalent to a Subaru in terms of capability, so that’s why the Subaru comparison is common.

Sponsored